Request a Free Estimate
    Financing options available for qualified applicants.

    Disadvantages of Roof Repair Over Roof Replacement

    Dealing with roofing issues can sometimes be tricky. While it’s good to address such problems immediately, make sure that your solution is effective and long-lasting. Otherwise, you may find yourself in the same situation again and again.

    Disadvantages of Roof Repair Over Roof Replacement

    Typically, when your roof has been damaged, your main options are repairs and replacement. In some cases, especially those involving minor issues, repairs are usually enough. Meanwhile, for more serious roofing problems or extensive roof damage, roof replacement is typically recommended. However, since roof replacement comes with significant expenses, it’s common for homeowners to be hesitant in undertaking such a project.

    Factors to Consider When Deciding to Repair or Replace Your Roofing

    Your roofing contractors should be able to recommend the best way to deal with the issues in your roof system. Since they have to conduct a thorough inspection, this enables them to assess the current condition of your roofing and determine what needs to be done. But to further help you in making a decision on whether to repair or replace your roof, below are some major considerations that you should take into account:

    damaged roof

    Age of Your Roof

    If your roof is relatively new or nowhere near the end of its expected lifespan, it might be enough to do some patching or repair work. Furthermore, if your roof is generally in good condition with only minor issues, a full replacement might not be necessary just yet.

    But if you have no idea when your roof was installed, or you’re simply not sure, your roofer can help you figure it out by checking for specific components. It’s always best to consult experts, especially if you’re not sure about the current state of your roof.

    Extent of Damage

    Severely damaged roofs require extensive repairs. But even though roof repair can be done successfully, and it usually costs less than a replacement, it may not prove to be a long-lasting and cost-effective solution. For example, if your decking or other inner roofing layers have been damaged, fixing all of these parts may require a lot of effort, so it might actually make more sense to get a new roof instead. Of course, you can’t ignore these inner components and only repair, say, the shingles. Fixing the shingles and neglecting all the other components and structures that support the roof shingles will only compromise the quality of your new shingles. They won’t last as long if their decking is already in poor shape.


    Leaks aren’t easy to detect when they are just starting to form. That’s why small leaks are often only found during a roof inspection. If your roofer was able to find a small leak during one of these inspections, patching would likely be enough to stop the problem or prevent it from turning into a bigger leak.

    roof leak

    It becomes an entirely different conversation when the leak has already spread to other parts of your roof or home. In this case, you might be dealing with extensive damage already, and a roof replacement may be needed. Let your roofers assess the condition of your roofing system so that they can offer appropriate recommendations.


    Roof replacement certainly needs planning, especially in terms of expenses. Roofing costs are typically significant, so you really do have to prepare a budget for it. Some homeowners opt to have repairs done while they are still in the process of saving up. You can choose to do it this way if you’re keen on paying in cash.

    However, if your roofing situation requires replacement immediately, you can look into different types of roof financing – such as government loans, Home Equity Line of Credit and credit cards. Some contractors may be able to offer in-house financing or flexible payment plans, too. Don’t hesitate to inquire about these, especially if you need an emergency replacement.

    Roof Shingles vs. Roof Structure

    Shingles are generally easy to replace. But if the underlying structure of your roof is also damaged, replacing only the shingles can only offer a temporary solution. It may not be practical as well because your new shingles are only as good as the structure that supports them. Make sure to talk to a roofing professional so that you’ll get a good understanding of your options before making a final decision.

    Disadvantages of Roof Repair Over Replacement

    roofer fixing a roof

    Cost is usually the main reason why people tend to be more inclined to choose repair over replacement. But while repairs are generally cheaper in the short term, the expenses could easily add up if the need for repairs becomes more frequent. That said, always consider the factors mentioned earlier – roof age, extent of damage, compromised parts, leaks and budget – to help with your decision.

    Make sure to consult professionals, too. Have your roof inspected so that you can get a full view of its current condition. Choose a roofing contractor with a good reputation. Whether you ultimately choose to repair or replace your roof, you should see to it that you are working with a trustworthy company that can do quality work.

    Advantages of Roof Replacement

    In general, roof replacement can offer more advantages than roof repair. Below are some of them:

    new roofing

    Peace of Mind

    With a new roof, you can rest assured that it won’t give you any headaches for several years. You don’t have to worry about major problems, except in cases of severe storms or extreme weather events. Just make sure to keep your roof well-maintained. Invest in regular roof maintenance so that you can maximize your roof’s lifespan. It would also be great if you could choose a low-maintenance roofing material. This way, the cost of upkeep and the maintenance itself won’t overwhelm you.

    Improved Energy Efficiency

    Your roof is a significant factor in your home’s energy efficiency. By replacing your old roof, you can have the opportunity to switch to a more energy-efficient material and ensure improved comfort inside your home. That said, do research on the different roofing materials that are energy-efficient, and discover the best roofing options for the type of climate that you experience in your region. It would help you a lot if you could talk to local roofing contractors since they know your area well. Surely, they would be able to offer the best recommendations to you.

    Enhanced Curb Appeal

    This is especially important if you plan on selling your home in the near future. A new roof can make your home more attractive to potential buyers, giving you a chance to sell your property at a favorable price.

    Orion Home Improvements LLC is a locally owned company that provides quality roofing services. Our team ensures exceptional workmanship and customer service for every client. We always aim to give our customers a positive experience, making sure that their projects are done professionally. Other services that we provide include siding replacement, seamless gutter installation, window and door installation, and more. Call us at (571) 354-0331, or fill out our contact form to request a free quote. We serve customers in Fairfax and Alexandria, VA.

    orion home improvements
    Our Testimonials
    ProviaDoor Logo Master Elite NRCA Logo BBB Veteran-Owned Small Businesses Logo James Hardie Logo Virginia Association Of Roofing Professionals Logo Certainteed Logo
    Free Estimate
    Scroll To Top